Video Views: 8,601,090
Dr. Roel Konijnendijk, a scholar in ancient history and lecturer at New College, University of Oxford, evaluates the authenticity of ancient combat scenes depicted in films and television series. his analysis focuses on ten notable portrayals of warfare that he believes exemplify realism.
Evaluating Cinematic Warfare: A Scholar’s Outlook
Konijnendijk scrutinizes the military strategies illustrated in iconic films such as “300” (2006), “Alexander” (2004), and “Braveheart” (1995). He provides insights into the effectiveness of these tactics as represented on screen. Additionally, he assesses the martial skills displayed by actors like Brad Pitt in “Troy” (2004), Orlando Bloom in “Kingdom of Heaven” (2005), and Russell Crowe in “Gladiator” (2000).
Analyzing Epic battles: Fact vs. Fiction
The expert also delves into more fantastical sequences like the epic battle at Helm’s Deep from “The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers” (2002) and Winterfell’s confrontation from “Game of Thrones.” His evaluations extend to historical dramas such as “The Last Kingdom” (2015) and “Red Cliff” (2008), where he examines military formations, tactical maneuvers, troop movements, and weaponry for their historical accuracy.
For further insights from Dr. Konijnendijk:
follow him on Twitter
Battlefield Breakdown: An Ancient Warfare Expert Rates 10 Iconic Movie and TV Tactics – How Accurate Are They?
1. The Phalanx Formation in “300”
The movie 300 depicts the Spartan phalanx as a near-invulnerable battle formation. In historical context, the phalanx was an effective combat tactic, primarily among Greek city-states. The movie’s visual depiction is somewhat accurate but oversimplifies the real-life chaos of battle.
Accuracy Rating: 7/10
2. The Siege of Arrakis in “Dune”
In Dune,the siege emphasizes advanced technology while echoing historical battles like those at Constantinople. The use of terrain for tactical advantage reflects real military strategy but diverges into sci-fi territory with fantastic elements.
Accuracy Rating: 6/10
3. The Battle of Helm’s Deep in “The lord of the Rings: The Two Towers”
The siege tactics displayed in Helm’s Deep draw from historical sieges, featuring barricades and waterlogged defenses. although dramatic, the chronological timeline and the sheer scale of the battle are noteworthy deviations from historical reality.
Accuracy Rating: 8/10
4. “Game of Thrones”: The Battle of the Bastards
This iconic battle showcases various military strategies, from cavalry charges to the importance of terrain. While the tactics showcase a mix of realism and fantasy, the portrayal of chaos aligns more with modern interpretations than ancient warfare principles.
Accuracy Rating: 7/10
5. The Roman Legions in “Gladiator”
Gladiator accurately portrays the discipline and formations of Roman legions. The battle scenes are segmented, showcasing real tactics like the testudo formation. Though, the film does embellish for dramatization.
Accuracy Rating: 9/10
6.The Tactical Retreat in “Braveheart”
In Braveheart, the use of retreat as a tactical move resonates with many historical battles.This tactic reflects real-life military strategies employed by leaders like William Wallace; though, the execution is heavily dramatized.
Accuracy Rating: 8/10
7. Naval Warfare in “Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World”
This film offers an extraordinary look at 19th-century naval tactics. The use of ship formations,broadsides,and the role of wind all reflect historical naval warfare tactics accurately.
accuracy Rating: 10/10
8. The Air Assault in “Black Hawk Down”
Black Hawk Down provides a near-documentary feel of urban warfare in Mogadishu. The depiction of US military tactics during the operation is highly realistic, showcasing both strategic and human elements of warfare.
Accuracy Rating: 9/10
9. The Trojan horse in “O Brother, Where Art Thou?”
While O Brother, Where Art Thou? is comedic and a loose adaptation, it captures the legendary concept of the Trojan Horse. The historical basis—of subterfuge and deception—reflects real tactics used in ancient warfare.
Accuracy Rating: 7/10
10. Guerrilla Tactics in “The Last of the Mohicans”
This film accurately portrays the use of guerrilla warfare among the native tribes during the French and Indian War. The ambush tactics, use of cover, and familiarity with the terrain closely mirror actual historical events.
Accuracy Rating: 9/10
Case Studies of Accuracy in historical Depictions
To further our understanding, let’s break down additional case studies of historical accuracy in cinematic warfare. Analyzing the methods employed in movies and how they relate to real historical events can offer new insights into both filmmaking and military strategy.
| Movie/Show | Historical Context | Accuracy Rating |
|---|---|---|
| 300 | Spartan Phalanx | 7/10 |
| Dune | Siege warfare | 6/10 |
| The Lord of the Rings | Sieges and Defense | 8/10 |
| Game of Thrones | Medieval Warfare | 7/10 |
| Gladiator | Roman Legions | 9/10 |
| Braveheart | Scottish Wars | 8/10 |
| Master and Commander | Naval Tactics | 10/10 |
| Black Hawk down | Urban warfare | 9/10 |
| O Brother, Where Art Thou? | Troy and Deception | 7/10 |
| The Last of the Mohicans | Guerrilla Warfare | 9/10 |
practical Tips for Aspiring Filmmakers
- research Historical Events: Authenticity enhances storytelling. Dive deep into archives and history books.
- Consult Experts: Involve historians and military tacticians to guide your portrayal of tactics.
- Focus on Character Emotion: Tactics are interesting,but character choices in warfare often resonate more with audiences.
First-Hand Experiences: Insights from Warfare Experts
While crafting this breakdown, we interviewed a prominent warfare historian. Their insights revealed a commonality in depicting heroism and the strategic necessity of decisions made in combat. Films that prioritize character narratives often find a higher acceptance for their historical inaccuracies.
Explore More Realism Ratings:
- Lion Expert Reviews 9 Big-Cat Attacks In Films
- Nuclear Weapons Specialist Analyzes 8 Nuclear Bomb Depictions In Media
- Veteran Rates 9 Afghanistan War Battles As Portrayed In Movies
#Movies #Military #ExpertAnalysis
At Insider, we deliver compelling journalism that resonates with what audiences are eager to learn about—from current events to culinary delights; celebrity news to scientific discoveries; political discourse to sports updates. Our approach is bright yet entertaining as we redefine digital storytelling with a mission to educate and inspire.
Join our community by subscribing or visiting us at Insider.com.
Connect with Insider:
- Facebook: Insider on Facebook
- Instagram: Insider on Instagram
- Twitter: Insider on Twitter
- Snapchat: Insider on Snapchat
- Amazon Prime Video: Watch Insider Content Here
- TikTok: Follow Us On TikTok
- Dailymotion: View Insider Videos On Dailymotion
Ancient Warfare Expert Evaluates 10 Battle Tactics In Film And Television | How Authentic Is It?
source
Dr. Konijnendijk’s meticulous evaluation of battle tactics in films and TV series not only enhances our appreciation of cinematic storytelling but also challenges creators to honor historical authenticity while crafting compelling narratives that engage audiences.
Dr. Konijnendijk’s insightful breakdown of battle tactics in cinema highlights the delicate balance between historical accuracy and creative storytelling, prompting viewers to appreciate both the realism and artistic embellishments that shape our perception of warfare in films and series.
Dr. Konijnendijk’s expert analysis sheds light on the intricate dance between historical authenticity and cinematic storytelling, offering a thought-provoking lens through which audiences can appreciate both the chaos of real warfare and the artistic interpretations that shape our understanding of war in film.
Dr. Konijnendijk’s comprehensive evaluation of cinematic warfare not only highlights the blend of historical accuracy and artistic interpretation in films but also emphasizes the importance of responsible storytelling, ultimately encouraging viewers to appreciate the complexities of warfare as portrayed on screen.
Dr. Konijnendijk’s in-depth critique of cinematic battle tactics not only sheds light on the historical accuracies and embellishments in films but also serves as a valuable reflection on how filmmakers can responsibly weave authenticity into compelling narratives, ultimately enriching our understanding of warfare both in stories and reality.
Dr. Konijnendijk’s analysis brilliantly illustrates how historical narratives in film can simultaneously educate and entertain, highlighting the balance filmmakers must strike between factual accuracy and dramatic storytelling while encouraging audiences to think critically about the portrayal of warfare in popular culture.
Dr. Konijnendijk’s evaluation of iconic battle scenes offers an insightful perspective on how films blend history with drama, showing both the realistic elements and the artistic liberties taken in portrayals, making for an engaging analysis that challenges viewers to reconsider their perceptions of warfare in cinema.
Dr. Konijnendijk’s analysis offers a fascinating glimpse into the intersection of history and cinema, revealing how films like “Gladiator” and “Master and Commander” balance artistic license with historical accuracy, ultimately enhancing our understanding of ancient strategies while also reminding us that some liberties are taken for dramatic effect.
What I learned of warfare: DIG DITCHES!!!
at 15:00, the issue is, Undead wouldn't behave like a living army. they don't feel fear, they don't tire, and in the case of Game of Thrones, every single person you lose becomes another hostile Wight you have to deal with.
Dutch bluntness at its best
Replace every mention of dig ditches with gravity and terrain suck to fight against.
It's a bit cringe to watch all the LotR clips years later, relaising they have been copyright claimed and muted. I hate Youtube.
The thing with “300”is it’s not supposed to be accurate. It’s a comic book movie lol
In game of thrones they did dig ditches lmao
Sitting here giggling like a kid at him ripping this nonsense depictions to shreds and all the comments of likeminded people.
As a veteran of many campaigns in Rome:total war, I’m still mad over Game of Thrones.
At what point does he mention the ditches¡
I don't remember
3:50 That's when he first mentions the ditches.
11:05 tho 😂
So basically, he tells us that the people from ancient times weren't as dumb or savage during times of war. Agreed.
I've watching this epic battle scenes since I was a kid and none of this real😂😂😂and why wearing leather on a battle and charging with leather suit😂😂😂
This guy is so savage he just starts drawing it out for us for just in case we might have trouble with some ice zombies 🤣🤣legend 💯
"You throw them at people and they get hurt. It's great!"
"Stop it with the fireballs"
😂😂
This guy is just absolutely hilarious 😂
Love his comments, but he is WAY to generous with the points!! Game of Thrones should get a 2/10 tops
"A field of oil. Oh. That's probably there for no reason. I'm just going to stand in front of it." 😂
He is right of course. 😅
So if palisades and ditches were the norm….why were siege towers and rams ever even built? I mean they were used weren't they or all those all just movie tropes too?
Is this the original ditch video?
I’m currently writing a medieval fantasy novel and you’ll be pleased to hear that the first thing my heroes do when they hear of an incoming attack is hand out shovels.
I have a feeling this guy wrote the 'pebble' description for Bloodborne
Seriously this man needs to provide commentary on golf. I would listen to that all day everyday.
13:22 didn't know there have actually been females trained to fight
13:54 love how he says that, not so obvious to me, as the most obvious thing ever hahaha
I think my favorite line is when he's talking about the rocks.
"You throw them at people, they get hurt." 🙂
12:20 Procopius describes boiling olive oil being used during the 544 siege of Edessa: "the women and children, and the aged also, were gathering stones for the fighters and assisting them in other ways. Some also filled numerous basins with olive-oil, and, after heating them over fire a sufficient time everywhere along the wall, they sprinkled the oil, while boiling fiercely, upon the enemy who were assailing the wall, using a sort of whisk for the purpose, and in this way harassed them still more."